• Home
  • Blog
  • 68% of Searches Now End Without a Click

The change we are seeing with AI is easier to understand as a change in what the machine is doing, rather than as a change in technology.

The old system kept an index of web pages and ranked them. You asked a question, it decided which pages were most likely to contain the answer, and it handed you ten of them. The judgment it made was about which page to send you to. It never answered anything itself.

The new system answers. It pulls material from a number of sources, assembles a response in its own words, and shows you that. Sometimes there may be a few citations, depending on the model and what it decides to return specific to your query. The judgment it makes is about who is worth naming.

Your website is no longer a destination it is choosing between. It is one of many raw materials it may or may not draw on, and the reader may never learn it was involved.

That distinction has a consequence you can measure.

The clicks stop

The Pew Research Center ran the most careful observational study of this to date. Rather than asking people what they do, Pew tracked what they did: 68,879 real Google searches from 900 American adults, in March 2025.

When an AI summary appeared at the top of the results, 8% of users clicked any traditional search result. When no summary appeared, 15% did. The click rate roughly halved.

More striking is what happened to the citations inside the summary itself. One percent of users clicked one. The links are there. Essentially nobody follows them.

Pew also found that users were more likely to end their session entirely when a summary appeared, 26% versus 16%. The answer was the end of the errand.

Google says that study is wrong

It is worth noting that Google publicly disputed Pew’s findings, calling the methodology flawed and the sample unrepresentative. Google has an obvious interest in the answer, but so does everyone else in this argument, and the objection is not frivolous.

So the more useful question is whether anyone tested it a different way and got a different result.

In January and February of 2026, researchers at the Indian School of Business and Carnegie Mellon ran what appears to be the first randomized field experiment on the question. Rather than observing behavior, they controlled it: 1,065 desktop Chrome users were randomly assigned to standard Google Search or to a version with AI summaries stripped out, using a custom extension.

Outbound clicks fell by roughly 40% on queries where an AI summary appeared. Searches ending with no click at all rose from 54% to 72%.

Two independent methods, one observational and one experimental, produced the same finding.

AI is not a small slice of search

The two studies disagree about how often AI summaries appear. Pew found them on 18% of searches in March 2025. The randomized study found them on 42% of queries in early 2026. Different samples and different methods account for some of that. Ten months of aggressive rollout account for the rest.

Across all searches, the direction is consistent. Similarweb data analyzed by SparkToro found that 68% of American searches in the first four months of 2026 ended without a click on anything. Out of every 1,000 searches, 276 sent someone to a website.

Users are not unhappy with this

One finding from the randomized study deserves greater attention: users who received AI summaries reported no meaningful drop in satisfaction. They were not frustrated. They were not looking for the links and failing to find them.

Separately, Pew found in a follow-up survey of 5,153 adults that about one in five people find AI summaries extremely or very useful. That is not overwhelming enthusiasm. But indifference is worse news than hostility for anyone hoping this reverses. Products people dislike get abandoned. Products people mildly prefer become the default.

What this means for how a law firm gets found is the subject of our new report.

RebuttalPR is a litigation communications firm built for the plaintiffs’ bar. Through earned media, thought leadership, and the stories your cases produce, we build the authority and reputation that clients look for and that AI relies on. Our team are veterans of AAJ, state trial lawyer associations, and Public Justice. We do this work because we believe in the plaintiffs’ bar and the clients it serves. If something here raises a question about your own firm, reach us at the form below.

Discover Insights & Trends

Featured Stories